Well, it's a pretty rose, but it isn't likely 'La Ville de Bruxelles', now, is it? In my search for Old Garden Roses and Hybrid Rugosa roses that might have a chance to resist the Rose Rosette virus, I had ordered this Damask from Heirloom Roses in 2019. Last year, it bloomed just a couple of blooms, a small wisp of a plant, and I was primarily only concerned for its survival. This year, it's blooming profusely, and whatever it is, it doesn't seem to be what it's supposed to be, at least not yet.
The color is not far off 'La Ville de Bruxelles', a clear deep pink, and the rose only bloomed once last year (and will, I presume only once this year), but everything else about it is wrong. These blooms are not the tightly packed, fully double blooms of the Damask, nor are they the expected 3-4" size. The blooms on my specimen are easily 5-6" in diameter, loosely organized and semi-double to double, appearing more modern than any Damask rose I've seen in the past. They open, as you can see below, to a more flat form with golden center stamens and an often white strip The foliage of the bush is matte green, and healthy as anything, but the canes are long and sprawling, with small thorns. Fragrance is strong, with sweet OGR tones, certainly no hint of the spice of a rugosa.
For someone who likes to know the denizens of his garden, it's a bit frustrating to receive a rose that isn't it's namesake, and it is unusual for Heirloom Roses to mislabel a rose in my experience. I suppose it's possible that this bush will gain more double blooms as it grows and matures, but that sumptuous color is just far too perfectly pink for an Old Garden Rose, no mauve at all, just pink. And the size! These blooms are enormous, bigger than any other rose in my garden. I considered Hybrid Perpetual 'Paul Neyron' due to the blooms size, but, again, the color is just too perfect and even 'Paul Neyron' is more double than this seems to be; not to mention that my rose doesn't rebloom as a Hybrid Perpetual does. A cross between something modern and Rosa gallica is, I think, a far more likely provenance for this unknown creature of my garden.
I shouldn't care, I know, since it shows no signs of Rose Rosette Disease, is cane hardy without protection from a very cold winter, and it has great color and fragrance. What more can I really ask of a rose? It will stay in my garden, just another mystery among mislabeled plants and my sometimes inaccurate plant maps. In fact, I should just close my trap and accept it, because the bees certainly seem to like it. Nature knows best.